Book Information

Title: Longstreet: The Confederate General Who Defied the South
Author: Elizabeth Varon
Publisher: Simon & Schuster
Publication Year: 2023
Pages: 496
Genre: American Civil War History, Biography, Reconstruction History

Overall Rating: ★★★★★

Summary

Elizabeth Varon’s “Longstreet: The Confederate General Who Defied the South” represents a groundbreaking reassessment of one of the Civil War’s most misunderstood figures. Through meticulous new research and a broader historical perspective, Varon rescues James Longstreet from decades of character assassination orchestrated by Lost Cause mythologists. Her comprehensive biography reveals not only Longstreet’s superior tactical abilities during the war but also his crucial and courageous role in Louisiana’s Reconstruction, which ultimately led to his systematic vilification by former Confederate allies who could not forgive his collaboration with Ulysses S. Grant’s administration.

Varon’s work demonstrates how Longstreet’s post-war choices to support Republican Reconstruction policies and maintain his friendship with Grant made him a target for Southern historians and writers who needed scapegoats to preserve the mythology of Confederate heroism. The result is a powerful corrective to generations of historical distortion that reveals Longstreet as perhaps the most pragmatic and forward-thinking of the major Confederate generals.

Strengths

Revolutionary New Research

Varon’s exhaustive archival work uncovers previously overlooked correspondence, military records, and newspaper accounts that fundamentally alter our understanding of Longstreet’s character and contributions. Her research into Louisiana state archives reveals the extent of Longstreet’s involvement in Republican politics and his genuine efforts to build a biracial coalition during Reconstruction. These findings directly contradict decades of scholarship that portrayed him as an opportunistic turncoat.

Comprehensive View of Reconstruction Leadership

Perhaps Varon’s most significant contribution lies in her detailed examination of Longstreet’s role as a Southern leader during Reconstruction in Louisiana. Rather than simply abandoning his past, Longstreet emerged as a genuine advocate for racial reconciliation and political cooperation. Varon shows how he used his military reputation to legitimize Republican policies among white Southerners while working to protect the rights of formerly enslaved people. His appointment as surveyor of customs in New Orleans and later as U.S. Marshal demonstrated his commitment to making Reconstruction work practically rather than merely symbolically.

The Grant Friendship and Political Courage

Varon provides compelling evidence that Longstreet’s post-war relationship with Grant was based on genuine friendship and shared pragmatic vision rather than mere political calculation. She documents how their pre-war friendship at West Point evolved into mutual respect during the war and blossomed into a partnership for national healing afterward. Longstreet’s willingness to risk his reputation in the South by publicly supporting Grant’s presidential campaigns and policies demonstrates a level of political courage rarely acknowledged by previous historians.

Systematic Debunking of Lost Cause Mythology

One of Varon’s most valuable contributions is her systematic dismantling of Lost Cause propaganda that transformed Longstreet from hero to villain. She meticulously traces how former Confederates like Jubal Early and historians like Douglas Southall Freeman created a narrative that blamed Longstreet for Confederate defeats, particularly at Gettysburg. Varon shows how these attacks intensified after Longstreet’s political apostasy, revealing them as character assassination designed to protect the reputations of generals like Robert E. Lee who remained politically acceptable to white Southerners.

Addressing the Shelby Foote Problem

Varon directly confronts the influence of popular historians like Shelby Foote, whose romanticized “Narrative of the Civil War” perpetuated Lost Cause myths about Longstreet for new generations. She demonstrates how Foote’s literary approach, while compelling, relied on discredited sources and Confederate propaganda rather than rigorous historical analysis. Varon’s evidence-based approach provides a necessary corrective to Foote’s influential but historically problematic work, showing how popular history can sometimes do more harm than good to our understanding of the past.

Personal Reflection

This book fundamentally changed my understanding of Civil War leadership and the politics of historical memory. Before reading Varon’s work, I had accepted the conventional wisdom that generals like Lee represented the pinnacle of Confederate military leadership. However, Varon’s evidence convinced me that Longstreet, not Braxton Bragg or even Robert E. Lee, should be regarded as the true hero of Confederate generalship.

Longstreet’s tactical superiority becomes clear when examined objectively. His defensive strategies at Second Bull Run and Chickamauga demonstrated a sophisticated understanding of modern warfare that his contemporaries lacked. More importantly, his willingness to question Lee’s aggressive tactics at Gettysburg revealed strategic thinking that could have changed the war’s outcome. The fact that he was undermined by other generals during the war and then scapegoated afterward speaks to the political dynamics within Confederate leadership that historians have too often ignored.

What struck me most powerfully was Varon’s demonstration of how character assassination during the Lost Cause period wasn’t just about rewriting military history—it was about punishing political apostasy. Longstreet’s real crime wasn’t losing battles; it was choosing principle over popularity in supporting Reconstruction. This realization helped me understand how historical narratives can be weaponized to serve political purposes long after the events they describe.

Reading this book also made me reconsider how we evaluate historical figures. Longstreet’s post-war courage in supporting racial equality and national reconciliation should enhance rather than diminish his historical reputation. The fact that it didn’t—that it actually led to his vilification—reveals the deep moral failings of the society that rejected his leadership.

Areas for Consideration

Dense Archival Detail

While Varon’s extensive research strengthens her arguments, the wealth of documentary evidence occasionally slows the narrative pace. Some readers may find the detailed discussion of Louisiana political machinations challenging to follow without deep background knowledge of Reconstruction politics.

Limited Military Analysis

Although Varon successfully rehabilitates Longstreet’s military reputation, readers seeking detailed tactical analysis of his battlefield performance may want additional sources. The book focuses more on the politics of military reputation than on operational details.

Historical Significance

Varon’s biography represents a watershed moment in Civil War historiography. By demonstrating how Lost Cause mythology deliberately distorted Longstreet’s reputation, she provides a template for examining other historical figures who may have been similarly maligned. Her work shows how political considerations in the post-war period shaped historical memory in ways that obscured rather than illuminated the past.

The book’s broader significance lies in its demonstration that historical truth often conflicts with popular memory. Varon’s evidence that Longstreet was arguably the most tactically sound Confederate general challenges fundamental assumptions about Civil War leadership. More importantly, her revelation of his principled stand during Reconstruction offers a model of moral courage that transcends regional loyalties.

Classroom Applications

For high school students, this book offers valuable lessons in:

• Historical Methodology: Understanding how historians use evidence to challenge conventional wisdom
• Critical Thinking: Questioning popular narratives and examining their sources
• Character Analysis: Evaluating historical figures based on their actions rather than their reputations
• Reconstruction Studies: Understanding the complexities of post-war politics and racial reconciliation
• Media Literacy: Recognizing how popular historians can perpetuate historical myths

Contemporary Relevance

Varon’s work speaks directly to contemporary debates about historical memory and the politics of commemoration. Her demonstration of how Longstreet was vilified for supporting racial equality offers insights into ongoing struggles over Civil War memory and Confederate monuments. The book shows how historical narratives can be manipulated to serve political purposes and why rigorous scholarship matters for public understanding.

Conclusion

“Longstreet: The Confederate General Who Defied the South” stands as a masterpiece of historical rehabilitation that fundamentally alters our understanding of Civil War leadership and Reconstruction politics. Varon’s meticulous research and compelling narrative reveal James Longstreet as a figure of genuine heroism—not for his Confederate service, but for his post-war courage in supporting justice and reconciliation over regional loyalty and racial prejudice.

This book succeeds in rescuing a genuinely important historical figure from decades of character assassination while providing broader lessons about how historical memory is constructed and manipulated. Varon’s systematic debunking of Lost Cause mythology and her direct challenge to popular historians like Shelby Foote make this essential reading for anyone interested in how history is written and rewritten.

The greatest strength of Varon’s work lies in her ability to show how Longstreet’s story illuminates larger truths about American political courage and the cost of principled leadership. His willingness to risk his reputation for the sake of national healing offers a model of moral leadership that transcends the specific circumstances of his era.

Recommended For

• Advanced high school students studying Civil War and Reconstruction history
• Educators seeking to challenge Lost Cause mythology in their classrooms
• Anyone interested in understanding how historical memory is constructed and contested
• Readers who want to understand the real complexities of post-Civil War politics
• Students of military history interested in tactical analysis and leadership studies

Final Assessment: Elizabeth Varon has produced a definitive biography that not only rehabilitates James Longstreet’s reputation but also provides crucial insights into the politics of historical memory. This book will be essential reading for anyone seeking to understand the Civil War and Reconstruction beyond the myths that have long obscured their true meaning.

---

This is part of a collection of book and movie reviews intended to help educators. I have read/screened of of these books and at times included excerpts in my classroom over the years and highly recommend them. Keep in mind that not all classrooms are the same and every educator should evaluate school and district recommendations before using any book, movie, or podcast in classes.
To read more of my reviews follow the link.

This is one of several articles in my brief history series about the US Civil War and its ever evolving place in American history. What began in 2010 as a blog series about the 150th anniversary has evolved into so much more.